Simply Cookies vs Edible Cookie: Which Pre-Made Cookie Is Worth Buying?

Simply cookies and edible cookie products offer different experiences for anyone craving a ready-to-eat dessert without the baking.

Updated 30 Jul 2026 3 min read 7 sections

Simply cookies and edible cookie products solve the same problem (delivering a fresh-baked treat without turning on your oven) but they take different approaches.

Simply Cake Co simply cookies — Simply cookies£8.99Image from the merchant

Simply cookies typically arrive as fully baked, ready-to-eat treats with a soft, cake-like texture that stays fresh for several days. They’re designed for immediate enjoyment straight from the package, with flavors ranging from classic chocolate chip to seasonal varieties.

Edible cookie products, on the other hand, often lean into the raw cookie dough experience. They’re safe to eat unbaked thanks to heat-treated flour and pasteurized eggs, giving you that nostalgic spoon-licking experience in a food-safe format. Some brands also offer baked versions, but the raw dough format is what sets this category apart.

The key difference comes down to texture and intent. Simply cookies deliver a finished bakery experience, while edible cookie products cater to dough lovers who want that rich, dense, slightly gritty mouthfeel without salmonella risk.

Taste and Texture: How They Compare

Check each product description for texture, flavor and storage notes.

If you prefer a lighter, more traditional baked cookie, simply cookies win. If you grew up sneaking bites of dough and want that exact experience safely, edible cookie products deliver.

Price and Value Breakdown

Neither option is cheap compared to homemade, but convenience has a cost. Here’s how the value stacks up:

Feature	Simply Cookies	Edible Cookie
Shelf life	5-7 days	2-3 weeks refrigerated
Serving size	1 large cookie per pack	1-2 oz dough portion
Customization	Limited to available flavors	Can mix into ice cream, brownies

For current pricing on both options, check the latest deals and our exclusive code before ordering. We’ve seen prices fluctuate by season, and the 10% sitewide discount can make a noticeable difference on multi-pack orders.

Simply Cake Co edible cookie dough tub — Edible cookie dough tub£8.99Image from the merchant

The edible cookie dough tub format offers better per-ounce value if you plan to portion it yourself, while individually wrapped simply cookies cost more but eliminate waste if you only want one serving at a time.

Who Should Buy Which Option

Choose simply cookies if you:

Want a grab-and-go dessert that feels like a bakery purchase
Prefer a less-sweet, fluffier texture
Plan to serve guests or bring treats to an event
Don’t have reliable refrigeration for storage

Choose edible cookie products if you:

Simply Cake Co brownie in a mug using brownie mix — Brownie in a mug using brownie mix£3.50Image from the merchant

Crave raw cookie dough specifically
Want longer shelf life and flexible portioning
Like to customize your desserts (dough mixes into milkshakes, tops ice cream, or becomes a brownie in a mug using brownie mix mix-in)
Enjoy very sweet, dense treats

If you’re buying for kids, simply cookies tend to be more universally appealing. Edible cookie dough skews toward adults who understand the nostalgic appeal.

Other Simply Cake Co Treats Worth Considering

If neither option quite hits the mark, the store offers solid alternatives that might better match your dessert needs:

Simply Cake Co photo brownie — Photo brownie£12.00Image from the merchant

Photo brownie: Customizable brownies with edible images, perfect for celebrations where cookies feel too casual
Easter cookies to buy: Seasonal decorated cookies that deliver more visual impact than standard simply cookies
Proper coffee or proper tea: Pair either cookie option with a quality hot beverage to balance the sweetness

According to Simply Cookies, texture and freshness are the top factors customers care about when choosing pre-made cookies.

How to Store and Serve Each Option

Proper storage extends the life and quality of both products:

For simply cookies:

Keep sealed in original packaging or an airtight container at room temperature
Warm for 8-10 seconds in the microwave to refresh the texture
Freeze for up to 3 months; thaw at room temperature for 30 minutes before serving

For edible cookie products:

Refrigerate immediately after opening
Let sit at room temperature for 5 minutes before eating if you prefer a softer texture
Scoop with a cookie scoop for clean portions
Freeze unused portions in a freezer bag for up to 2 months

Both options benefit from being served slightly warm if you want to maximize flavor. For the best deal on either choice, grab the current discount code before placing your order.

Our Bottom Line

Simply cookies win for anyone who wants a traditional, ready-to-enjoy baked cookie. Edible cookie products are the better pick if you’re specifically craving raw dough or want a more versatile base for building other desserts.

Simply cookies suit quick snacks and lunch boxes, and edible cookie dough suits sundae toppings. Your choice depends entirely on whether you want a baked cookie experience or the thrill of safe-to-eat dough.

Questions

Can you bake edible cookie dough from Simply Cake Co?

Most edible cookie dough products are formulated to be eaten raw and may not bake properly due to different ratios of ingredients. Check the specific product packaging, as some brands offer dual-purpose doughs that work both ways.

How long do simply cookies stay fresh after delivery?

Simply cookies typically stay soft and fresh for 5 to 7 days when stored in an airtight container at room temperature. You can extend their life by freezing them for up to three months.

Are edible cookie products safe for kids to eat raw?

Yes, edible cookie products use heat-treated flour and pasteurized eggs to eliminate the bacteria risks associated with traditional raw dough. They're designed to be safe for all ages to enjoy unbaked.

Which option is better for gifting?

Simply cookies tend to work better as gifts because they look and feel like bakery treats, arrive ready to eat, and don't require refrigeration. Edible cookie dough needs to stay cold and is better suited for personal enjoyment.

Do I need to refrigerate simply cookies?

No, simply cookies are baked and shelf-stable at room temperature for up to a week. Refrigeration can actually dry them out, so store them in a sealed container in a cool, dry place instead.

Can I use the same discount code for both cookie types?

Yes, the Simply Cake Co sitewide discount code applies to both simply cookies and edible cookie products, along with most other items in the store.